How to Rebalance Your Portfolio in Recent Volatile Markets

Introduction: The Importance of Portfolio Rebalancing in Volatile Markets

Portfolio rebalancing has become essential for investors facing today’s unpredictable markets. The surge in global economic disruptions—from inflation spikes to currency swings and changing interest rates—means asset values and portfolio compositions can shift quickly. The stock market, for example, may see dramatic gains or losses in short periods, pulling your portfolio far from its original structure. Therefore, maintaining portfolio rebalancing as a regular practice is key to managing risk, staying on track with your investment objectives, and avoiding emotional, reactionary changes that could harm returns.

What Is Portfolio Rebalancing?

At its core, portfolio rebalancing is the process by which investors periodically realign asset allocations to maintain a chosen risk profile. This practice involves selling some investments that have outperformed to buy those that have underperformed, restoring your portfolio’s original target mix. For instance, if a portfolio was originally set at 60% stocks and 40% bonds, but stocks rally and grow to 70%, portfolio rebalancing would reduce your equity holdings and repurchase bonds to return to the 60/40 allocation.

Investors use rebalancing to stay in control of their financial plans. It counters the natural tendency for winning assets to occupy a larger share of your investments, exposing you to higher risk. By proactively restoring balance, portfolio rebalancing supports long-term stability and keeps your returns more predictable.

Why Portfolio Rebalancing Matters in Volatile Markets

Portfolio rebalancing gains increased significance during volatile markets because market swings accelerate allocation drift. High stock gains can leave you exposed to steeper losses if markets drop suddenly. Conversely, neglecting underperforming areas may mean missing out on their eventual recovery. Maintaining your asset allocation also preserves diversification, which is crucial when one asset class starts behaving unpredictably.

Research from Vanguard and Morningstar continually finds that disciplined portfolio rebalancing can enhance long-term returns and control risk, especially through crisis periods. Without rebalancing, portfolios risk becoming concentrated in volatile assets, undermining efforts to protect against downturns. Emotional investors might be tempted to chase performance or sell in panic—both behaviors that historically have led to poor outcomes. By adhering to a plan, investors can ride out volatility with greater confidence and reduced regret.

How Does Portfolio Rebalancing Work?

There are two main approaches to portfolio rebalancing: periodic and threshold-based. Periodic rebalancing means resetting asset allocations at regular intervals, such as quarterly or annually. Threshold-based rebalancing, on the other hand, triggers action whenever an allocation drifts by a set amount (e.g., if equities exceed their target by 5%). Many modern investors use a combination, scheduling reviews but also intervening if market swings are especially severe.

Suppose you own three major asset classes—stocks, bonds, and real estate. If real estate surges in value while bonds fall, your portfolio shifts away from your original plan. You would sell some real estate holdings and buy more bonds until each asset returns to your desired allocation. Automated investing platforms, or robo-advisors, can assist this process by alerting you to drift and even executing trades as needed. However, investors must also weigh transaction fees, taxes, and rules around each asset, as frequent trades may create unwanted costs.

Strategic Approaches and Best Practices

Periodic Rebalancing: Many investors set a routine to review portfolios every three, six, or twelve months. This schedule is easy to remember and ideal for those who prefer fewer transactions. The main advantage is simplicity, though extreme market swings between scheduled reviews may go unnoticed.

Threshold Rebalancing: This approach means tracking asset values more closely and acting only when allocations diverge by a meaningful margin—often 5% or more—from targets. This strategy can keep risk under control amid turbulent price swings but may increase trading costs. Still, for larger or more complex portfolios, it offers peace of mind in volatile periods since you act immediately when risks emerge.

Hybrid Models: Some investors choose a hybrid approach, performing a scheduled review but also watching for significant allocation drifts. This combination helps balance discipline, responsiveness, and cost efficiency.

Automating the Process: Robo-advisors and advanced brokerage accounts can automate portfolio rebalancing, alerting you or even executing trades when your allocation drifts. This technology reduces the risk of emotional or neglected rebalancing while optimizing for taxes and trading expenses.

Regardless of strategy, investors must be mindful of taxes, especially if rebalancing in taxable accounts. Realizing capital gains can trigger federal or state tax bills, so many investors structure rebalancing around retirement or tax-advantaged accounts when possible. Strategic tax-loss harvesting can offset some of these costs when certain assets have declined in value.

Common Portfolio Rebalancing Mistakes to Avoid

During volatile markets, some common missteps can undermine your rebalancing strategy. Emotional reactions—panic selling or chasing hot sectors—often lead to poor long-term results. Investors also sometimes ignore transaction costs, which can accumulate quickly with frequent trades. Failing to consider taxes, especially capital gains, can surprise even experienced investors and erode returns.

Another frequent error is allowing indecision or inertia to delay action. Just as dangerous is rigidly rebalancing without considering whether your goals or personal circumstances have changed. Reviewing your risk tolerance and financial goals at each rebalancing gives you the chance to adjust allocations as necessary while remaining aligned with your long-term plans.

Rebalancing Frequency and Timing: How Often Should You Rebalance?

No universal answer exists because the ideal frequency depends on your preferences, goals, and market activity. Most experts suggest rebalancing at least once per year, but more frequent reviews may be warranted when markets are volatile or your portfolio has a large equity component.

Some investors use monthly, quarterly, or semi-annual schedules, while others rely on preset allocation drift thresholds. For example, an investor may decide to rebalance whenever any asset class shifts 5% or more from its target. A hybrid strategy, combining periodic reviews with a threshold alert, provides an extra layer of responsiveness without demanding constant oversight.

Remember, the costs of rebalancing—especially taxes or trading fees—should factor into your decision. It is often more efficient to direct new investments (like regular contributions or dividends) toward underweighted assets, thus reducing the need for active selling and associated expenses.

Case Studies: Portfolio Rebalancing in Action

Case Study 1: Surging Tech Sector in 2021–2022
During the tech rally, an investor’s initial 60/40 portfolio drifted as tech stocks soared. At year-end, the portfolio reached 75% equities. By rebalancing, the investor sold a portion of tech stocks and bought bonds, realigning with their risk tolerance. When volatility returned and tech corrected sharply in 2022, the decision to rebalance shielded the portfolio from deeper losses.

Case Study 2: The 2020 COVID Crash and Recovery
A balanced portfolio experienced significant equity losses in early 2020. The investor, committed to their rebalancing plan, bought stocks at lower prices while selling assets that had held up better (like government bonds). As markets recovered, the portfolio outperformed peers who had panicked and sold stocks during the downturn.

Portfolio Rebalancing and Asset Correlation

Asset correlation measures how investments move in relation to each other. High correlations reduce the benefit of diversification, while low or negative correlations increase stability. During volatile times, correlations often shift—as seen when stocks and bonds both fall or rise together. Regular portfolio rebalancing helps mitigate this risk by enforcing discipline, reducing overexposure to assets that have moved in tandem, and actively maintaining true diversification.

The Role of Behavioral Finance in Portfolio Rebalancing

Behavioral biases can deeply influence rebalancing. Fear of missing out (FOMO), loss aversion, and recency bias all tempt investors to avoid selling recent winners or buying weaker performers. Automatic or rules-based rebalancing counters these tendencies. Learning from past patterns and maintaining discipline increases your chances of meeting financial goals without succumbing to market-driven emotions.

Tactical Portfolio Rebalancing: Special Considerations in 2024

In 2024, new factors—such as evolving regulations, increased market automation, and the rise of alternative asset classes—affect what effective portfolio rebalancing looks like. For example, cryptocurrencies or private equity may now be mainstream in diversified portfolios. However, these assets can be illiquid, hard to value, or especially volatile, presenting unique rebalancing challenges. Investors should update allocations, incorporate new asset types carefully, and remain vigilant about liquidity issues when rebalancing in today’s fast-moving environment.

In addition, sustainable investing (ESG) has gained popularity, pushing some investors to rebalance in favor of environmentally or socially responsible holdings. When shifting to these new asset classes, review overall risk, market correlations, and liquidity, ensuring that your rebalancing process adapts to changing personal and market standards.

Conclusion: Staying Proactive with Portfolio Rebalancing

Consistent portfolio rebalancing provides the discipline needed to navigate volatile markets, control risk, and support long-term success. By choosing a strategy that fits your needs, leveraging automation where appropriate, and keeping an eye on costs and taxes, you can stay on course even when markets shift unpredictably. Above all, rebalancing requires reviewing both your portfolio and your personal goals regularly, ensuring actions you take reflect not only market conditions but also your evolving life circumstances.

For more insights and strategies, visit our category on Investing and Diversification to expand your financial knowledge and empower your investment decisions.